Radio Free never takes money from corporate interests, which ensures our publications are in the interest of people, not profits. Radio Free provides free and open-source tools and resources for anyone to use to help better inform their communities. Learn more and get involved at radiofree.org

Republican Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell on Tuesday made the sweeping claim that the legislative filibuster has “no racial history at all” and further insisted that historians don’t dispute his view—an assertion that historians immediately disputed.

“Strom Thurmond disagrees,” tweeted historian Patrick Wyman, referring to the late Republican senator from South Carolina whose 24-hour filibuster against the Civil Rights Act of 1957 remains the longest in U.S. history.

During a press briefing Tuesday, McConnell offered a full-throated defense of the filibuster amid growing calls by Senate Democrats to significantly weaken or abolish the 60-vote rule, which in its current form gives the minority party enormous power to block legislation. Progressive advocacy groups and some Democratic lawmakers have taken to describing the filibuster as a “Jim Crow relic” to denote its past use as a weapon against civil rights legislation.

“It has no racial history at all. None. So, there’s no dispute among historians about that,” said McConnell, who stood by the GOP’s intention to use the filibuster to block the For the People Act, Democratic legislation aiming to expand ballot access as Republicans press ahead with sweeping voter suppression measures at the state level.

“Historian of the 20th century South here. I dispute Mitch’s statement,” responded Charles Westmoreland, a professor of history at Delta State University in Mississippi. “The filibuster has a ton of ‘racial history.'”

Kevin Kruse, professor of history at Princeton University, offered a non-exhaustive list of filibuster use against civil rights and anti-lynching legislation over the past 150 years:

Adam Jentleson, executive director of the Battle Born Collective and author of a new book on the history of the Senate, wrote Tuesday that “McConnell’s argument that the filibuster ‘has no racial history at all’ is the new ‘the Civil War wasn’t about slavery.'”

“For more than a century the filibuster was widely understood to be primarily dedicated to maintaining white supremacy and blocking civil rights,” Jentleson noted, quoting a defense of the filibuster offered in 1949 by the late Democratic senator and arch-segregationist Richard Russell of Georgia.

In recent weeks, McConnell has repeatedly risen to the defense of the legislative filibuster and threatened to unleash “chaos” on the upper chamber if Democrats target the 60-vote rule, which is currently standing in the way of immigration and labor law reform, gun safety legislation, climate action, and other top priorities of the majority party.

“McConnell is scared,” argued Eli Zupnick of the advocacy group Fix Our Senate. “He knows the filibuster is his key to maintaining power from the minority and preventing Dems from delivering on their promises, and he sees his grip on that weapon of partisan obstruction slipping away.”

Citations

[1] Patrick Wyman on Twitter: "Strom Thurmond disagrees. On the other hand, though, if he can stand there and lie and have credulous reporters repeat his words verbatim, why not just say whatever he feels like?… https://t.co/ePv6nkCgU5" ➤ https://twitter.com/Patrick_Wyman/status/1374433234994434053[2] 'Weapon of Mass Obstruction': Durbin Blasts Filibuster on Senate Floor ➤ https://www.commondreams.org/news/2021/03/16/weapon-mass-obstruction-durbin-blasts-filibuster-senate-floor[3] 'A Jim Crow Relic That Must Be Abolished': Demand to End Filibuster Grows ➤ https://www.commondreams.org/news/2021/01/17/jim-crow-relic-must-be-abolished-demand-end-filibuster-grows[4] As House Passes For the People Act Without One GOP Vote, Progressives Warn Bill Is 'Dead' If Senate Filibuster Remains ➤ https://www.commondreams.org/news/2021/03/04/house-passes-people-act-without-one-gop-vote-progressives-warn-bill-dead-if-senate[5] 'Jim Crow in a Suit and Tie': Georgia Senate Approves Massive Assault on Voting Rights ➤ https://www.commondreams.org/news/2021/03/09/jim-crow-suit-and-tie-georgia-senate-approves-massive-assault-voting-rights[6]https://twitter.com/chwestmo7/status/1374472435462901764[7] The Recount on Twitter: "Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell: The filibuster has "no racial history at all. None. There's no dispute among historians." (This is exceedingly untrue.)… https://t.co/wTFJl5DP0O" ➤ https://t.co/8K44VydQNl[8] The Recount on Twitter: "Mitch McConnell: The filibuster has "no racial history at all. None. There's no dispute among historians." (This is exceedingly untrue.) https://t.co/8K44VydQNl… https://t.co/dHMFvQFdj6" ➤ https://twitter.com/therecount/status/1374433682119749637?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw[9] Kevin M. Kruse on Twitter: "Filibuster against civil rights bill, 1874 Filibuster against civil rights bill, 1875 Filibuster against a pension for a black official, 1906 Filibuster against confirmation of a black official, 1909… https://t.co/onGg3upHkI" ➤ https://t.co/FGBIGvARkQ[10] Kevin M. Kruse on Twitter: "Filibuster against civil rights bill, 1874 Filibuster against civil rights bill, 1875 Filibuster against a pension for a black official, 1906 Filibuster against confirmation of a black official, 1909… https://t.co/onGg3upHkI" ➤ https://twitter.com/KevinMKruse/status/1374467896840097792?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw[11] Kevin M. Kruse on Twitter: "Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1921 Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1922 Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1925 Filibuster against monument to black WWI veterans, 1926… https://t.co/aFJqNdzOpp" ➤ https://t.co/YZMOdFS4xI[12] Kevin M. Kruse on Twitter: "Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1921 Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1922 Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1925 Filibuster against monument to black WWI veterans, 1926… https://t.co/aFJqNdzOpp" ➤ https://twitter.com/KevinMKruse/status/1374467901760020480?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw[13] Kevin M. Kruse on Twitter: "Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1935 Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1938 Filibuster against bill targeting racial discrimination in employment, 1945 Filibuster against Truman's civil rights proposals, 1948… https://t.co/8yxu1bXyuy" ➤ https://t.co/mZ1fkZNqWa[14] Kevin M. Kruse on Twitter: "Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1935 Filibuster against anti-lynching bill, 1938 Filibuster against bill targeting racial discrimination in employment, 1945 Filibuster against Truman's civil rights proposals, 1948… https://t.co/8yxu1bXyuy" ➤ https://twitter.com/KevinMKruse/status/1374467906487033872?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw[15] Kill Switch | Adam Jentleson | W. W. Norton & Company ➤ https://wwnorton.com/books/9781631497773[16] Adam Jentleson 🎈 on Twitter: "Great question. McConnell's answer is false. His office is trying to clean it up but he said what he said. For more than a century the filibuster was widely understood to be primarily dedicated to maintaining white supremacy and blocking civil rights. Here's Russell in 1949. https://t.co/A5GLiPDzbg… https://t.co/nXAvnzeUGj" ➤ https://twitter.com/AJentleson/status/1374445644690067468/photo/1[17] Critics Say 'Scorched Earth' Threat Over Filibuster Shows McConnell 'Getting Scared' ➤ https://www.commondreams.org/news/2021/03/16/critics-say-scorched-earth-threat-over-filibuster-shows-mcconnell-getting-scared[18] House Passage of Historic Union Rights Bill Intensifies Pressure on Dem Senators to 'Stop Hiding Behind' Filibuster ➤ https://www.commondreams.org/news/2021/03/10/house-passage-historic-union-rights-bill-intensifies-pressure-dem-senators-stop[19] 'End the Filibuster and Pass Gun Safety Laws. Now': Colorado Massacre Intensifies Demands for Action ➤ https://www.commondreams.org/news/2021/03/23/end-filibuster-and-pass-gun-safety-laws-now-colorado-massacre-intensifies-demands[20] 'Now Is the Moment to Deliver': Sunrise Movement Says Biden Climate Ambitions Require Abolition of Senate Filibuster ➤ https://www.commondreams.org/news/2021/01/27/now-moment-deliver-sunrise-movement-says-biden-climate-ambitions-require-abolition[21] Eli Zupnick on Twitter: "Sen. McConnell is scared. He knows the filibuster is his key to maintaining power from the minority & preventing Dems from delivering on their promises, & he sees his grip on that weapon of partisan obstruction slipping away. Let's keep this momentum going to #FixOurSenate!… https://t.co/U8QBsZl6nf" ➤ https://twitter.com/elizupnick/status/1371837741911191558