Radio Free never takes money from corporate interests, which ensures our publications are in the interest of people, not profits. Radio Free provides free and open-source tools and resources for anyone to use to help better inform their communities. Learn more and get involved at radiofree.org

ANALYSIS: By Alexander Gillespie, University of Waikato

We live, to borrow a phrase, in interesting times. The pandemic aside, relations between the superpowers are tense. The sudden arrival of the new AUKUS security agreement between Australia, the US and UK simply adds to the general sense of unease internationally.

The relationship between America and China had already deteriorated under the presidency of Donald Trump and has not improved under Joe Biden.

New satellite evidence suggests China might be building between 100 and 200 silos for a new generation of nuclear intercontinental missiles.

At the same time, the US relationship with North Korea continues to smoulder, with both North and South Korea conducting missile tests designed to intimidate.

And, of course, Biden has just presided over the foreign policy disaster of withdrawal from Afghanistan. His administration needs something new with a positive spin.

Enter AUKUS, more or less out of the blue. So far, it is just a statement launched by the member countries’ leaders. It has not yet been released as a formal treaty.

As The Conversation reports, the initiative coincides with the Morrison government deciding it is best for Australia to accelerate the production of a more capable, integrated, nuclear-powered submarine platform — at a vastly higher cost — with the US and the UK.

Australia’s previous A$90 billion deal with the French company DCNS to build up to 12 submarines has been canned.

The Indo-Pacific pivot
The new agreement speaks of “maritime democracies” and “ideals and shared commitment to the international rules-based order” with the objective to “deepen diplomatic, security and defence co-operation in the Indo-Pacific region”.

“Indo-Pacific region” is code for defence against China, with the partnership promising greater sharing and integration of defence technologies, cyber capabilities and “additional undersea capabilities”. Under the agreement, Australia also stands to gain nuclear-powered submarines.

To demonstrate the depth of the relationship, the agreement highlights how “for more than 70 years, Australia, the United Kingdom and the United States have worked together, along with other important allies and partners”.

At which point New Zealand could have expected a drum roll, too, having only just marked the 70th anniversary of the ANZUS agreement. That didn’t happen, and New Zealand was conspicuously absent from the choreographed announcement hosted by the White House.

Having remained committed to the Five Eyes security agreement and having put boots on the ground in Afghanistan for the duration, “NZ” appears to have been taken out of ANZUS and replaced with “UK”.

Don’t mention the nukes
The obvious first question is whether New Zealand was asked to join the new arrangement. While Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has welcomed the new partnership, she has confirmed: “We weren’t approached, nor would I expect us to be.”

That is perhaps surprising. Despite problematic comments by New Zealand’s trade minister about Australia’s dealings with China, and the foreign minister’s statement that she “felt uncomfortable” with the expanding remit of the Five Eyes, reassurances by Ardern about New Zealand’s commitment should have calmed concerns.

One has to assume, therefore, that even if New Zealand had been asked to join, it might have chosen to opt out anyway. There are three possible explanations for this:

The first involves the probable provision to Australia of nuclear-powered military submarines. Any mention of nuclear matters makes New Zealand nervous. But Australia has been at pains to reiterate its commitment to “leadership on global non-proliferation”.

Similar commitments or work-arounds could probably have been made for New Zealand within the AUKUS agreement, too, but that is now moot.

The dragon in the room
The second reason
New Zealand may have declined is because the new agreement is perceived as little more than an expensive purchasing agreement for the Australian navy, wrapped up as something else.

This may be partly true. But the rewards of the relationship as stated in the initial announcement go beyond submarines and look enticing. In particular, anything that offers cutting-edge technologies and enhances the interoperability of New Zealand’s defence force with its allies would not be lightly declined.

The third explanation could lie in an assumption that this is not a new security arrangement. Evidence for this can be seen in the fact that New Zealand is not the only ally missing from the new arrangement.

Canada, the other Five Eyes member, is also not at the party. Nor are France, Germany, India and Japan. If this really was a quantum shift in strategic alliances, the group would have been wider — and more formal than a new partnership announced at a press conference.

Nonetheless, the fact that New Zealand’s supposedly extra-special relationship with Britain, Australia and America hasn’t made it part of the in-crowd will raise eyebrows.

Especially while no one likes to mention the elephant – or should that be dragon? – in the room: New Zealand’s relationship with China.The Conversation

Dr Alexander Gillespie is professor of law at the University of Waikato. This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons licence. Read the original article.


This content originally appeared on Asia Pacific Report and was authored by APR editor.

Citations

[1] Alexander Gillespie – The Conversation ➤ https://theconversation.com/profiles/alexander-gillespie-721706[2] University of Waikato on The Conversation ➤ https://theconversation.com/institutions/university-of-waikato-781[3]https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/10/us/politics/biden-xi-china.html[4] Subscribe to read | Financial Times ➤ https://www.ft.com/content/13621676-a2bd-42b3-bd62-809542c2f8c8[5] Hypersonic Missiles: A New Arms Race – The Diplomat ➤ https://thediplomat.com/2021/06/hypersonic-missiles-a-new-arms-race/[6] Australia to build nuclear submarines in a new partnership with the US and UK ➤ https://theconversation.com/australia-to-build-nuclear-submarines-in-a-new-partnership-with-the-us-and-uk-168068[7] Australia to build nuclear submarines in a new partnership with the US and UK ➤ https://theconversation.com/australia-to-build-nuclear-submarines-in-a-new-partnership-with-the-us-and-uk-168068[8] C'est fini: can the Australia-France relationship be salvaged after scrapping the sub deal? ➤ https://theconversation.com/cest-fini-can-the-australia-france-relationship-be-salvaged-after-scrapping-the-sub-deal-168090[9] Why nuclear submarines are a smart military move for Australia — and could deter China further ➤ https://theconversation.com/why-nuclear-submarines-are-a-smart-military-move-for-australia-and-could-deter-china-further-168064[10] ANZUS at 70: Together for decades, US, Australia, New Zealand now face different challenges from China ➤ https://theconversation.com/anzus-at-70-together-for-decades-us-australia-new-zealand-now-face-different-challenges-from-china-163546[11]https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-58540915[12] North and South Korea conduct missile tests as arms race heats up | Reuters ➤ https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/nkorea-fired-unidentified-projectile-yonhap-citing-skorea-military-2021-09-15/[13] Joe Biden's botched Afghanistan exit is a disaster at home and abroad long in the making | CNN Politics ➤ https://edition.cnn.com/2021/08/16/politics/afghanistan-joe-biden-donald-trump-kabul-politics/index.html[14] Joint Leaders Statement on AUKUS | The White House ➤ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021/09/15/joint-leaders-statement-on-aukus/[15] Why nuclear submarines are a smart military move for Australia — and could deter China further ➤ https://theconversation.com/why-nuclear-submarines-are-a-smart-military-move-for-australia-and-could-deter-china-further-168064[16] French company DCNS wins race to build Australia's next submarine fleet: experts respond ➤ https://theconversation.com/french-company-dcns-wins-race-to-build-australias-next-submarine-fleet-experts-respond-58060[17] Australia, US and UK form AUKUS under a new nuclear defence pact - NZ Herald ➤ https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/australia-us-and-uk-form-auukus-under-a-new-nuclear-defence-pact/PMMR46UAWAKXCQB2DXM6MZXATY/[18] ANZUS at 70: Together for decades, US, Australia, New Zealand now face different challenges from China ➤ https://theconversation.com/anzus-at-70-together-for-decades-us-australia-new-zealand-now-face-different-challenges-from-china-163546[19]https://www.gcsb.govt.nz/about-us/ukusa-allies/[20] AUKUS: Jacinda Ardern welcomes United Kingdom, United States engagement in Pacific, says NZ nuclear stance 'unchanged' | Newshub ➤ https://t.co/Ot3Ehi0R92[21]https://twitter.com/NewshubPolitics/status/1438288911558533124?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw[22] AUKUS: Jacinda Ardern welcomes United Kingdom, United States engagement in Pacific, says NZ nuclear stance 'unchanged' | Newshub ➤ https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2021/09/aukus-jacinda-ardern-welcomes-united-kingdom-united-states-engagement-in-pacific-says-nz-nuclear-stance-unchanged.html[23] Aukus submarines banned from New Zealand as pact exposes divide with western allies | New Zealand | The Guardian ➤ https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/sep/16/aukus-submarines-banned-as-pact-exposes-divide-between-new-zealand-and-western-allies[24] Facebook ➤ https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/124696892/yes-he-did-say-that-diplomats-scramble-to-contain-fallout-of-damien-oconnors-australiachina-comments[25] Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern reaffirms commitment to Five Eyes after UK media claims it's 'become four' | Newshub ➤ https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2021/04/prime-minister-jacinda-ardern-reaffirms-commitment-to-five-eyes-after-uk-media-claims-it-s-become-four.html[26] New AUKUS security pact: Jacinda Ardern says no change to relationships - NZ Herald ➤ https://t.co/zmjjWQWIuo[27]https://t.co/DEp13JUGWZ[28]https://twitter.com/nzherald/status/1438323102287548416?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw[29] Alexander Gillespie – The Conversation ➤ https://theconversation.com/profiles/alexander-gillespie-721706[30] University of Waikato on The Conversation ➤ https://theconversation.com/institutions/university-of-waikato-781[31] The Conversation: In-depth analysis, research, news and ideas from leading academics and researchers. ➤ https://theconversation.com/[32] ANZUS without NZ? Why the new security pact between Australia, the UK and US might not be all it seems ➤ https://theconversation.com/anzus-without-nz-why-the-new-security-pact-between-australia-the-uk-and-us-might-not-be-all-it-seems-168071