Radio Free never takes money from corporate interests, which ensures our publications are in the interest of people, not profits. Radio Free provides free and open-source tools and resources for anyone to use to help better inform their communities. Learn more and get involved at radiofree.org

A photo of Chinese President Xi Jinping with his eyes closed and frowning has been published by a number of media reports, sparking skepticism among Chinese-speaking social media users regarding its authenticity. Some claim that the photo has been digitally doctored.

But AFCL found the photo to be genuine. It was taken at “two sessions” in Beijing in early March by the Associated Press. 

The claim was shared on X, formerly known as Twitter, on March 13, 2024.

“This should be a fake picture made by foreign forces using AI,” the claim reads. 

The claim was shared alongside a photo of Chinese President Xi Jinping with his eyes closed and frowning. 

1.png
Screenshot of the Reddit post where its user questions whether the photo of Xi Jinping is genuine or not. (Reddit)

The photo was taken from a report published by the British tabloid Daily Mail Online on March 11.

“He [Xi] was spotted seemingly wincing after taking a sip of his brew while attending the closing session of the annual parliamentary meeting,” the caption of the photo reads. 

The photo has triggered doubts among Chinese-speaking social media users about whether it is authentic.

“Can anyone tell me if this photo is real and not?” one user asked in the comment section of Reddit. 

But AFCL found the photo to be genuine. 

Photo by AP

In the report by the Daily Mail, the publication attributed the photo to the Associated Press, or AP.

Keyword searches on AP’s archives found the corresponding photo published on March 11. 

“Chinese President Xi Jinping, rear, reacts after drinking from a cup at the closing session of the National People’s Congress held at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, Monday, March 11, 2024. (AP Photo),” the caption of the photo reads. 

2.png
Screenshot of AP archives. (AP)

The photo was also featured in AP’s “Pictures of the Week Asia Photo Gallery” on March 15. 

‘Rules’ in China

Radio Free Asia reported in 2011 that journalists in China have “rules” to follow when they report the activities of the country’s leaders. 

According to the rules, seen by RFA at that time, the images of the leaders must be “clean,” and that no one can be filmed sitting in an indecent position, smoking, playing with a pen, talking on the phone, or eating.

Other “rules” include not taking photos of fruits or people who are reading while holding umbrellas.

A former journalist Liu Yiming told RFA at that time that although these “rules” had always been unwritten at China’s state media, the media would definitely be held accountable by the authorities once violated. 

These regulations inevitably restrict press freedom. He said, adding that: “This definitely constitutes a restriction on press freedom.”

Edited by Taejun Kang and Malcolm Foster. 


This content originally appeared on Radio Free Asia and was authored by By Zhuang Jing for Asia Fact Check Lab.

Citations

[1] x.com ➤ https://twitter.com/i_loder/status/1767757977438896271[2] Storm in a teacup? Chinese President Xi Jinping appears to wince after sipping brew during annual congress as his communist party tightens grip on power | Daily Mail Online ➤ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13183627/Chinese-President-Xi-Jinping-annual-congress-communist-party.html